Newcastle United stadium supremo witnesses major St James' Park flaw as historic decision awaits

Newcastle United's stadium supremo Brad Miller emerged into the director's box smartly dressed and donning a flat cap as the Magpies' season hit crunch time.

As a huge surfer banner was unfurled at the Gallowgate End, the stage was set for Newcastle to get past Brighton and put themselves just 90 minutes away from another visit to Wembley. Newcastle did at least set the tone when going ahead through Alexander Isak's penalty mid-way through the first half but then the game got away from them.

Before the game Newcastle Supporters Club had stated on social media: "The tie must be settled on the day via extra time and penalties if required. Massive opportunity to progress, get behind the lads and play your part."

A play back of the game provides evidence of numerous chants during the match but one fan posted to Newcastle's official account on X: "That FULL leazes end was shocking. I could hear the players shouting - that’s how quiet it was. Strawberry Corner the only loud part. You have to sort that Leazes End right out. And quickly. It’s absolutely horrific there now."

In recent times, and in a bid to ease PSR concerns, the heart of the Leazes End was stripped out and replaced with a corporate hospitality area branded Wings with prices of £380 for adults and £285 for kids per game charged for category A games. As Newcastle ready themselves for fresh announcements on their stadium plans, a rethink could be needed regardless of whether they stay or go at St James' Park.

That thought won't be lost on Miller with Newcastle's atmosphere arguably not where it should be with the club on the brink of a trophy and fighting for the Champions League. Having a Yellow Wall style area of the new stadium - like Borussia Dortmund - would be a must at a new stadium.

However, that could be possible if the club get the green light to redevelop St James' with the Gallowgate End the perfect spot to bring in a singing section. Another fan commented on X: "The atmosphere today was absolutely dreadful considering we had a chance to reach a cup quarter final. For anyone thinking we’ll lose our atmosphere if we move to a new stadium, we’ve already lost it apart from the odd one-off game."

Chronicle Live understands that the two options for Newcastle are to stay at an increased St James' Park at around 60,000 or move to a new 70,000 bowl on the outskirts of the city. Whatever is decided it feels like a sit down with fan groups will be a must.