No ban on bike taxis in Karnataka: SC rejects state's appeal, favours regulation
The Supreme Court on Friday upheld the Karnataka High Court's order lifting the bike taxi ban, observing that the services were affordable, safer for women and should be regulated rather than banned.
by India Today News Desk · India TodayIn Short
- Supreme Court dismisses Karnataka's appeal against lifting bike taxi ban
- Court favours regulation over banning bike taxis citing safety, convenience
- Bench notes bike taxis are cheaper and safer for women with GPS
The Supreme Court on Friday dismissed the Karnataka government's appeal against a High Court order that lifted the ban on bike taxis, clearing the way for the services to return to roads across the state.
A bench of Justices Satish Chandra Sharma and N Kotiswar Singh upheld the High Court's January 23 order after hearing arguments from the state government, bike taxi aggregators and other parties. The court said regulating bike taxis was preferable to banning them.
While delivering the decision, Justice Sharma recalled a conversation with women in his office who used bike taxis, news agency PTI reported.
"I asked them, 'How do you come to my office?' They said on a motorbike because they do not have the money to hire a cab. I asked them, 'Why don't you take an auto?' They said, 'Sir, it is five times (the fare)'," he told the lawyers appearing in the case.
Justice Sharma said a bike taxi was safer for young girls as it had GPS. "It is better to regulate it than ban it. Bike taxis are already there in 25 states of the country," he added.
During the hearing, the Supreme Court questioned the Karnataka government's concerns over traffic congestion, noting that motorcycles occupy less road space than cars.
According to PTI, the state government's counsel argued that motorcycles and motor cabs were defined separately under the Motor Vehicles Act and that the state's rules for ride aggregators did not provide for bike taxis. He said aggregators had no inherent right to operate such services and cited a 2019 expert committee report that examined concerns over safety, congestion and pollution.
The Karnataka government said it was willing to consider allowing bike taxis in other parts of the state but would not permit them in Bengaluru.
Bike taxi aggregators told the court that nearly 4.5 lakh passengers benefited from their services in Karnataka. They relied on an earlier High Court ruling that had not been challenged and central government notifications issued in 2004 and 2024. The Centre submitted that its notifications allowed motorcycles to be used as taxis.
After considering the submissions, the bench dismissed the state's appeal. Senior advocates Vikas Singh and Parag Tripathi represented the Karnataka government, while senior advocate Abhishek Singhvi appeared for Uber.
The Karnataka government had challenged the High Court's January order on grounds including passenger safety, insurance coverage and the absence of safeguards for bike taxi riders. Several auto and taxi driver associations had also challenged the ruling, arguing that allowing bike taxis without similar regulatory requirements would adversely affect existing transport operators.
On January 23, the High Court lifted the ban and directed the state government to register motorcycles as transport vehicles and issue carriage permits to them. The order was passed on appeals filed by ANI Technologies, Uber India and Roppen Transportation Services against a single-judge bench order prohibiting bike taxis.
The Karnataka government had banned app-based ride-hailing aggregators from operating bike taxis on June 16, 2025. With the Supreme Court dismissing the state's appeal, the High Court order allowing bike taxis in Karnataka will remain in force.
- Ends