India now a rich country, but poor with sanitation: SC seeks action on waste crisis
The Supreme Court has pulled up authorities and citizens over poor sanitation and the failure to implement solid waste management rules, observing that India's economic progress is being undermined by inadequate waste management.
by India Today News Desk · India TodayIn Short
- Supreme Court criticises poor implementation of Solid Waste Management rules in India
- Emphasises sanitation affects national progress and societal image
- Highlights need for citizen cooperation and localised strategies
The Supreme Court has raised concerns over the failure to implement Solid Waste Management rules, saying India is now a rich country but continues to perform poorly on sanitation, news agency PTI reported.
A bench of Justices SVN Bhatti and NV Anjaria said poor sanitation and waste management undermine progress in other fields. It called for firm action by enforcement authorities, citizens, district collectors and local bodies.
The court was hearing appeals arising from National Green Tribunal orders on municipal corporations' compliance with environmental norms under the Solid Waste Management rules. It acknowledged that the first two phases -- initiating the process and setting up an administrative mechanism to monitor the implementation of the SWM Rules, 2026 -- were in place.
“The court notes that Bharat is now a rich country but has poor sanitation performance. The growth achieved in other fields is completely negated by the negative impact from this manageable dereliction by all the stakeholders,” the bench said in its November 17 order.
The court said poor sanitation and solid waste management affect the image of society and the country. It noted that comparable economies in India and abroad had achieved their sanitation and hygiene goals.
“Our existing resources make it possible, albeit through unwavering implementation by the statutory enforcing authorities and adherence by the citizens,” it said. After reviewing reports filed by the Supreme Court Monitoring Committee, or SCMC, the bench observed that each organ of the State had been working separately.
“The cogs (citizens) that connect them must work towards the objective for realising good results,” the bench said. It noted that the Constitution provides for separation of powers, Parliament enacted the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986, and the executive framed the SWM Rules, 2026.
The court said that despite the law and rules being in place, implementation of the SWM Rules, 2016 and 2026 had fallen short of Parliament's objective.
“Therefore, this court, as a repository of the constitutional right to a pollution-free environment, through SCMC, has taken the arduous task of issuing continuing mandamus to the local bodies. This effort of the Supreme Court through the SCMC is not the fifth wheel trying to drive the other four wheels. As already noted in our earlier orders, it is now or never. The SCMC's efforts will sunset into self-regulation by the contributors,” it said.
The bench acknowledged the scale of the problem and the effort needed to address it, while placing its trust in the SCMC and district collectors across the country.
“The court, with personal experience of the perfect and punctilious performance of two or three district collectors in the States where such rules were executed through district collectors, has relied only on the district collectors to achieve the objective of the court and the rules,” it said.
The court said its order was not meant as an inspirational message to district collectors but as a reminder of its expectations and their capabilities. It warned that failure to act could worsen the situation and leave it without a remedy.
“Therefore, the district collectors reinvent the needed strategies as per local requirements and, in a dynamic way, assist the chief secretaries and SCMC in implementing SWM Rules, 2026,” the court ordered.
Highlighting shortcomings in the approach, the court referred to its August 18 observation that unorganised residential, commercial and business sectors formed a major part of the problem.
“The report is silent on the notices served and on additional areas identified that warrant temporary disconnection of water/electricity for due compliance with the SWM Rules, 2026,” it said.
The court added that the report did not explain how public-private participation, proposed to ease pressure on financial resources, would work.
It also said the SCMC report did not address the statutory framework needed to use Corporate Social Responsibility initiatives to improve infrastructure. The bench said industries could not argue that pollution was generated in one place while their CSR contributions were made elsewhere.
The court pointed out several other shortcomings, issued additional directions for compliance and posted the matter for further hearing on January 12.
On August 18, the Supreme Court issued several directions on waste management and disposal, saying infrastructure needed to be expanded to meet the standards under the SWM Rules, 2026. It had described as regrettable the general attitude across society that “I am entitled to generate but not to cooperate and control the impact of solid waste management at the threshold”.
The proceedings began with a challenge by the Bhopal Municipal Corporation to directions concerning its obligations in handling municipal solid waste. Given the scale of the problem, the court later expanded the case nationwide and highlighted the lack of compliance with the SWM rules, PTI reported.
The SCMC was constituted under an earlier Supreme Court direction and includes several Union government secretaries and the secretary of the Central Pollution Control Board. The bench also directed district collectors to work with local bodies to identify all bulk waste generators in their jurisdictions.
The court's order underlined that effective implementation of waste management rules would require coordinated action by authorities, local bodies, industries and citizens, with district collectors and the SCMC overseeing compliance ahead of the next hearing on January 12.
- Ends