‘Paralyzed by Hope: The Maria Bamford Story’ Review: Ya Gotta Laugh to Keep from Crying, Right?

Sundance: If anything, Judd Apatow and Neil Berkeley's documentary about the beloved, wonderfully honest comedian suffers from having too much good material.

Here’s a problem any comedian would wish for: too much good material. Such is the case with Judd Apatow and Neil Berkeley’s documentary “Paralyzed by Hope: The Maria Bamford Story,” which focuses on a 1) very funny, compelling to watch subject with 2) an open-hearted spirit toward sharing her life and 3) enough ups and downs to frame half-a-dozen documentaries. Add in a litany of talking heads (from Bamford’s family to Ted Sarandos, Sarah Silverman to Conan O’Brien, Tig Notaro to Patton Oswalt, and many more), a wealth of archival material, and a final 20 minutes that feel “timely” to the extreme, and the duo’s doc feels overstuffed in ways both good and bad.

Think of it this way: “Paralyzed by Hope” is the rare “celebrity” documentary that actually would have benefitted from being split into two parts. What a world!

As a subject, Bamford is a dream: funny (duh), honest, willing to go there, disarming, and genuinely interested in talking about the worst shit she’s ever gone through in her life. She never goes so far as to say that the real win of her life has been her ability to share with others, but that’s simply baked in to everything she does, from her stand-up comedy to her philanthropy.

Late in the doc, fellow comedian Ron Funches says it best: Bamford’s existence is “a true net positive.” She just makes the world better, and Apatow and Berkeley’s film endeavors to show just how much that actually means, and how much it really took to get there.

Naturally, the film opens in silly fashion (and that peek-behind-the-curtain breeziness will be missed at certain points), with Apatow rolling up to Bamford’s home and slipping her 500 bucks to get chatting. That Bamford might be a bit reticent to share more about her life, despite the open nature of her stand-up act, is understandable, but any nerves are soon put way at ease.

Apatow and Berkeley wisely utilize a raft of talking heads throughout the film — the high stature of many of them makes it plain how important Bamford is in the comedy space (even if, later, they joke about how she’s spent decades being painted as the “next big thing”), and their own natural honesty allows them to insightful probe the Bamford mystique. O’Brien remains struck that the anxiety she chats about on stage is real. For Notaro, that level of uprightness is refreshing. Zach Galifianakis similarly marvels at how close Bamford is able to cut to the things that made her. Plenty of comedians can jaw about nerves or bad childhoods, but for Bamford, it’s literally not an act.

Bamford herself takes us back to her childhood home in suburban Duluth, where she talks about both her relatively “idyllic” childhood and the many facets of it that proved to be very hard indeed. The central four Bamfords — Maria’s sister, the also very funny Sarah, is on hand a lot, while archival footage and more recent interviews of their parents are a constant — were a tight group, but her mother Marilyn seemed to loom largest. Marilyn’s own mental health struggles not only mirror Maria’s (Bamford’s eventual diagnoses frame most of the film’s second half), but also deeply influence them, particularly the body issues that Bamford developed as a teen.

But Bamford is the last person on Earth to ever cast blame, and so when she opens up about the slow evolution of her various mental health issues, the level of intimacy she affords the audience is staggering. Fans of Bamford’s stand-up, of which we are treated to many clips of, spanning decades, will recognize some of her experiences, but she doesn’t flinch when talking about everything from suicidal ideation to bulimia, her problems with overspending and the heartbreaking ways in which her OCD rears its ugly head — mostly, through horrific intrusive thoughts that made a very young Bamford worry about what terrible crimes she might commit.

The honesty with which Bamford approaches all of this (and, yes, surely you must be sick of reading the word “honesty,” but there is simply no better term for who Bamford is and how she lives) is, as her fellow comedians have told us, real and refreshing and actually unique. Her years of comedy, plus an early foray into violin-based bits, have made Bamford a story- and joke-delivering machine, but it’s clear that she still carefully considers what she says and does. And yet, that never makes her feel somehow filtered or at a distance.

You’ll laugh! You’ll cry! And you’ll walk away with a hard-won appreciation for everything Maria Bamford is and hopes to be. Can we get a second part?

Grade: B

“Paralyzed by Hope: The Maria Bamford Story” premiered at the 2026 Sundance Film Festival. It is currently seeking U.S. distribution.

Want to stay up to date on IndieWire’s film reviews and critical thoughts? Subscribe here to our newly launched newsletter, In Review by David Ehrlich, in which our Chief Film Critic and Head Reviews Editor rounds up the best new reviews and streaming picks along with some exclusive musings — all only available to subscribers.