Liberty loses bid to bring legal action against equalities body - Jersey Evening Post
· Jersey Evening PostPosted inUK News
Liberty loses bid to bring legal action against equalities body
by 6 June 20256 June 2025
Share this:
- Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
- Click to share on X (Opens in new window) X
Human rights group Liberty has lost a bid to bring legal action against the equalities watchdog over its consultation in the wake of the Supreme Court’s ruling on gender.
The UK’s highest court ruled in April that the words “woman” and “sex” in the Equality Act 2010 refer to a biological woman and biological sex, after a challenge against the Scottish Government by campaign group For Women Scotland.
The Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC) is consulting on proposed amendments to part of its guidance, after interim guidance was published last month related to trans people’s use of certain spaces including toilets and participation in sports following the judgment.
The commission increased the length of time for feedback from an original proposal of two weeks to six weeks, but campaign group Liberty said that it should be at least 12 weeks, claiming the current period would be “wholly insufficient” and unlawful.
Liberty made a bid to bring a legal challenge over the length of the consultation, but in a decision on Friday afternoon Mr Justice Swift said it was not arguable.
In his ruling, Mr Justice Swift said: “There is no 12-week rule. The requirements of fairness are measured in specifics and context is important.”
“I am not satisfied that it is arguable that the six-week consultation period that the EHRC has chosen to use is unfair,” he added.
At the hearing on Friday, Sarah Hannett KC, for Liberty, said in written submissions that the Supreme Court’s decision “has altered the landscape radically and suddenly” and potentially changes the way trans people access single-sex spaces and services.
The barrister said this included some businesses preventing trans women from using female toilets and trans men from using male toilets, as well as British Transport Police updating its policy on strip searches, which have caused “understandable distress to trans people”.
Ms Hannett said a six-week consultation period would be unlawful because the EHRC has not given “sufficient time” for consultees to give “intelligent consideration and an intelligent response”.
She told the London court: “There is a desire amongst the bigger trans organisations to assist the smaller trans organisations in responding… That is something that is going to take some time.”
Later in her written submissions, the barrister described the trans community as “particularly vulnerable and currently subject to intense scrutiny and frequent harassment”.
Ms Hannett added: “There is evidence of distrust of both consultation processes and the commission within the community.”
Lawyers for the EHRC said the legal challenge should not go ahead and that six weeks was “adequate”.
James Goudie KC, for the commission, told the hearing there is “no magic at all in 12 weeks”.
He said in written submissions: “Guidance consistent with the Supreme Court’s decision has become urgently needed. The law as declared by the Supreme Court is not to come in at some future point.
“It applies now, and has been applying for some time.”
The barrister later said that misinformation had been spreading about the judgment, adding that it was “stoking what was already an often heated and divisive debate about gender in society”.
He continued: “The longer it takes for EHRC to issue final guidance in the form of the code, the greater the opportunity for misinformation and disinformation to take hold, to the detriment of persons with different protected characteristics.”
Mr Goudie also said that there was a previous 12-week consultation on the guidance at large starting in October 2024.
Related
Most read this week...
More from the JEP...
Calls grow for urgent ARFID support as mental health practitioners warn of gaps in care
6 June 20255 June 2025
Karate tournament set to rejuvenate the sport’s competitive side.
6 June 20256 June 2025
Assembly vote on French ID scheme extension will ‘make difference’ to visitor economy
6 June 20255 June 2025
BREAKING: Former police officer not guilty of grooming teenage girl
6 June 20256 June 2025
UK and World News
Kemi Badenoch refuses to kick Liz Truss out of Conservative Party
6 June 20256 June 2025
Teenager who died in ‘hit and run’ had just arrived in UK ‘for a better future’
6 June 20256 June 2025
Nurse jailed for murder of elderly patients faces wait in conviction appeal
6 June 20256 June 2025
D-Day veterans mark anniversary to ‘remember our friends who never came home’
6 June 20256 June 2025
Entertainment News
Ex-girlfriend of Sean Combs tells court of Las Vegas ‘hotel night’
6 June 20256 June 2025
Kim Kardashian to feature in new BBC documentary about Paris robbery
6 June 20256 June 2025
David Beckham to be awarded knighthood, reports suggest
6 June 20256 June 2025
Atomic Kitten’s Natasha Hamilton reveals skin cancer diagnosis
6 June 20256 June 2025
Read the latest free supplements
Read the Homelife, Le Rocher and a whole host of other subjects like ranging from cycling to travel.
View all our latest supplements now >