Darragh O'Brien says 'COP needs a reset' as deal on fossil fuels rejected
by AFP, https://www.thejournal.ie/author/afp/ · TheJournal.ieLAST UPDATE | 2 hrs ago
ENERGY MINISTER DARRAGH O’Brien has said that “COP needs a reset” after the EU rejected a climate deal that omits any mention of fossil fuels.
Speaking on RTÉ’s This Week programme, O’Brien described the proposals put forward as “insufficient” and that “didn’t recognise the gravity of the situation with regard to climate change”.
“There were good things in it around clean electrification, around zero waste, but fundamentally, they didn’t recognise the major problem and the major issue with fossil fuels
“To have a global climate conference that doesn’t recognise the single biggest contributor to climate change is unconscionable”, he added.
He said that “we didn’t want this outcome, but I think we could not accept a text that wasn’t grounded in reality”.
He noted that Saudi Arabia was one of the states “vociferously opposed” to the suggested amendments.
“They don’t hold the COP presidency, and it seemed to me that they had far too much influence”, O’Brien said.
“The presidency in Turkey worked very hard and the Australians worked very hard, but we got no compromises at every single stage”, he added.
Asked if the EU position has damaged the COP process, O’Brien insisted it has not but that “COP needs a reset”.
“I think if you look at since Dubai in COP 28, where there was the commitment for transitioning away from fossil fuel, and the climate has we’ve continued to heat.
“We had the hottest year in Europe ever, but the level of ambition has reduced, and that’s not the way it should be. We’ve got to bridge that gap”, he said.
He argued that the EU was right to reject the COP agreement, describing it as a necessary “reality check” on the lack of ambition and progress in the negotiations.
He defended the EU’s climate finance record, stating that it provides approximately 48% of global climate finance and is committed to improving access to funding for vulnerable countries.
In particular, O’Brien highlighted Ireland’s partnership with Tuvalu to advance the transition away from fossil fuels, noting that 27 countries now have transition roadmaps, compared with just one last year.
He defended Ireland’s climate record by pointing to the growth in renewable energy and falling emissions, while acknowledging the need to accelerate progress and promising a revised Climate Action Plan.
O’Brien said earlier that the climate summit was “hijacked by some oil states”.
Trócaire’s climate justice policy adviser Sinéad Loughran, who is at COP31, said the summit has “once again left climate vulnerable countries who have done the least to cause this crisis to pay the price of climate inaction”.
While she said the rejected texts “were clearly harmful and unacceptable”, she added that this ”does not allow the EU to cherry-pick which obligations they claim to fight for”.
“The hypocrisy of the EU and Ireland demanding fossil fuel references while ruling out climate finance prior to COP31, is stark in light of Ireland’s Transitioning Away from Fossil Fuels roadmap released just days ago,” said Loughran.
Advertisement
Loughran added that this “clarified what we already know; the Irish Government is not taking fossil-fuel phase out seriously”.
Meanwhile, Friends of the Earth Ireland described the failure to secure a COP31 deal as “shameful”.
“The failure even to mention fossil fuels in the deal meant there was no commitment to tackle the main cause of climate change. The lack of a deal represents a critical step backwards”, chief executive Deirdre Duffy said.
Green Party leader Roderic O’Gorman expressed his disappointment in the outcome but insisted that sometimes “no deal is better than a bad deal”.
“An agreement that failed to call out the role that fossil fuels play in driving climate change would have been absolutely pointless. The EU and in particular, the small island states that are most vulnerable to climate change, were right to take a stand on this issue,” stated O’Gorman.
‘Licence to keep polluting’
With expectations low, negotiations chief Australia had sought an overarching political agreement to capture what countries agreed at COP31 and send a signal about the future course of climate action.
But the EU and island nations threatened by rising seas protested after a proposed text did not mention fossil fuels by name.
Language around fossil fuels is fiercely opposed by petrostates oil-rich states such as Saudi Arabia. A Saudi official declined to comment when approached by AFP.
Threats of a walkout Saturday prompted Turkey and Australia to convene a hurried meeting between the EU and Saudi Arabia, but a compromise remained elusive.
The latest text introduces an oblique reference to a previous global deal in 2023 to shift the world away from fossil fuels – but stops short of naming them explicitly.
The text also proposed retaining a contentious push to expand carbon capture, a technology championed by the fossil fuel industry but criticised as costly and ineffective in cutting emissions.
Climate campaigners had urged countries to reject the deal.
“This text isn’t a climate plan. It’s a licence to keep polluting,” said Sara Shaw of environmental group 350.org.
Goal to electrify
The summit had been under pressure to show progress on tackling soaring greenhouse gas emissions in a year of climate-linked disasters from Europe to Nepal and Indonesia.
Facing blowback over fossil fuels, Turkey and Australia pointed to “electrification” as a way to cut heat-trapping emissions and bolster energy security.
This works by replacing technologies that burn fossil fuels directly – like diesel cars and gas heating — with electric alternatives.
The draft called for global efforts to boost the share of electricity in total final energy consumption to 35% by 2035 and the expansion of “clean energy”.
But it did not explicitly require that electrification be powered by renewable energy. Around one-third of global electricity is produced using coal and another fifth using fossil gas.
Countries have disagreed at COP31 over how to respond to the looming breach of the 1.5C warming target set under the Paris climate accord.
The latest draft expressed “deep concern” that global warming would cross 1.5C above pre-industrial levels in the next few years.
The talks also jammed over long-running complaints that rich nations are shirking their obligations to help developing nations confront climate change.
The removal of a $120 billion (€109.19 billion) target for climate adaptation angered developing nations.
With additional reporting by Hannah Power.
Sign Up
The Journal's climate change newsletter Follow the biggest news story of our times. Sign up for our monthly climate newsletter
Sign up
You are now signed up