I formed the NYPD’s tactical unit — Mamdani’s ‘disband’ foretells a painful lesson
· New York PostNew York City can reorganize its Police Department, as Mayor Zohran Mamdani announced Monday — but it can’t reorganize away the threats that require a fast, coordinated response.
As the commissioner who created the 600-officer Strategic Response Group and the 500-officer Counterterrorism Critical Response Command, I know why we built them — and what they were meant to do.
SRG was designed to give the NYPD a trained citywide force that could respond to major incidents, help control crime in troubled areas, support large public events and manage demonstrations that turn into serious disorder.
It was also trained to respond to the kind of active-shooter attack that can overwhelm ordinary patrol resources.
Advertisement
New York has learned, often painfully, that crowd management demands preparation, discipline and restraint.
The city’s history — from the Draft Riots of the Civil War era to the confrontations at Columbia University in 1968 — shows the cost when disorder spirals and police responses aren’t well planned.
Over the decades, the department tried different models: the Tactical Patrol Force, the Special Events Squad, borough task forces and the Disorder Control Unit.
Advertisement
Each reflected the needs and lessons of its time.
When the Crown Heights riots in 1991 made it clear that the department needed stronger planning, training and coordination, the Disorder Control Unit helped build a citywide approach.
Under then-Chief Lou Anemone, it became the backbone of the NYPD’s protest and civil-disorder planning for two decades.
But by 2014 it had weakened, as crowd-control skills became difficult to maintain across the department.
Advertisement
At the same time, the terror threat was changing.
The coordinated terrorist attacks in Mumbai and Paris showed how quickly multiple armed assailants could strike different locations — and how a city could be tested if specialized officers were not ready to respond.
That’s why we created the Critical Response Command within the Counterterrorism Bureau, a dedicated cadre trained for counterterrorism deployments.
The SRG served a different, broader purpose.
Advertisement
It gave the department a mobile force that could move quickly across the five boroughs in response to major incidents, crime patterns and civil disorder.
Its active-shooter training and equipment were deployed only for the exceptional moment when an armed attacker threatened lives — not as the ordinary tools of protest management.
The SRG response to the shooting at 345 Park Avenue in 2025 underscored why that readiness matters.
When an armed attacker opens fire in a crowded building, officers need the training and equipment to confront the threat.
Advertisement
When protests remained peaceful, the SRG’s responsibility was to protect that right and keep the public safe.
When unlawful violence or serious disorder emerged, highly trained officers responded with clear command, discipline and the minimum force necessary.
SRG officers were very skilled at responding to groups that moved quickly through the city, split into smaller subgroups, or tried to block streets and bridges.
A bicycle squad gave officers the ability to move with the crowd through congested areas, and to form a mobile barrier when needed.
Advertisement
That kind of preparation and training helped the NYPD respond to those intent on vandalism or disruption — without treating every demonstrator as a threat.
I cannot overstate the importance of training such a unit together, so that every officer knows and understands which tactics and strategies to use and how to coordinate them.
It’s valid to critique police tactics, and such criticism deserves serious attention.
A democracy must protect peaceful dissent, and police deployments must be lawful, proportionate and accountable.
Advertisement
But that doesn’t mean a city should strip itself of a specialized, coordinated response for fast-moving emergencies.
And it’s not clear that the new structure Mayor Mamdani has announced will preserve the capabilities New York certainly still needs.
As the city moves to disband the SRG and divide its responsibilities among new units, it must ensure that the NYPD can still mobilize quickly, coordinate across boroughs, protect peaceful demonstrators, respond to serious disorder and support officers confronting an active shooter.
Advertisement
Those abilities do not appear simply because an organizational chart changes.
They require trained people, regular practice, clear command and the right equipment for the threat.
New Yorkers deserve both a police department that respects constitutional rights — and one that’s prepared to act when lives are in danger.
We shouldn’t have to choose between those responsibilities.
Advertisement
The SRG was created to help the NYPD meet them both; the city’s new plan must be judged by whether it can do the same.
I’m confident that New York City’s current police commissioner, Jessica Tisch, fully understands those responsibilities and how to accomplish them.
William Bratton twice served as NYPD commissioner, and as chief of the LAPD, chief of the NYC Transit Police and commissioner of Boston Police.
Advertisement