Before Shenzhen: What Trump, Putin and Xi Want From an Unprecedented Three-Way Meeting, and What It Could Cost Ukraine

by · TFIPOST.com

US President Donald Trump, Russian President Vladimir Putin and Chinese President Xi Jinping are due to hold their first-ever three-way meeting on Thursday on the sidelines of the APEC summit in Shenzhen, Business Day reported. Whether it produces anything on Ukraine is unclear. Each leader arrives with a different goal, and the party most affected will not be in the room.

US-mediated talks between Russia and Ukraine resumed in Abu Dhabi on November 10-11, the first trilateral round since February. They produced an agreement in principle on a large-scale prisoner exchange, but the sides stayed divided on territory and postwar security guarantees. Moscow demands that Kyiv give up the whole of the Donbas. Zelensky has refused to withdraw.

Three days later, Reuters reported Zelensky as saying US negotiators had floated the idea of Ukraine withdrawing from Donbas in exchange for NATO membership. He said Kyiv would not retreat, but would put the question to a referendum if it received a full security package. This is Zelensky’s account, and I found no US confirmation.

How far will Trump go?

The signals are mixed. The Financial Times earlier reported that Washington had stopped linking security guarantees to territorial concessions and would not pressure Kyiv to give up land at the table. The same report said the US was discussing with Russia the return of American companies to its oil market after the war. Trump has also said post-war Ukraine will have a “different shape”, a phrase critics read as accepting territorial loss, and has said a deal is near. A US official said territory could be discussed only at leaders’ level and in the context of appropriate guarantees.

On guarantees for Ukraine, the US has asked Russia about arrangements modelled on NATO’s Article 5, according to the FT, while Secretary of State Marco Rubio has said Ukraine can obtain only guarantees that Russia accepts. That is the central dilemma: guarantees that Moscow must approve may be too weak for Kyiv, and guarantees Kyiv wants may be unacceptable to Moscow.

What each side wants

For Putin, the meeting itself is much of the prize. A Moscow-based analyst told Al Jazeera that simply being at the table makes Putin “first among equals” and shows Russia helping decide Europe’s security order, with Ukraine sidelined. Russia has also said Europeans should be kept out of the Abu Dhabi talks, and a senior Russian lawmaker has called the meeting a path towards a new Yalta.

For Trump, the stated focus is nuclear arms control. He has said he is open to talks if Xi wants them. Analysts quoted by Al Jazeera see a push for visible deal-making after the midterms, in which Democrats won both chambers of Congress. Putin’s camp argues that this weakens Trump’s hand on Ukraine, since a Democratic Congress could send more money to Kyiv. That is one side’s assessment.

For Xi, the aim is less clear. German President Frank-Walter Steinmeier said Xi told him the meeting would not be about Ukraine and that Europeans must sit at the table, according to Germany’s DPA. China has also said it is not realistic to ask it to join trilateral nuclear disarmament talks. Beijing nonetheless has influence over Moscow. Trump reportedly asked Xi in Beijing in May to push Putin back to negotiations, according to the South China Morning Post, and Kyiv accuses China of serving as an economic lifeline for Russia.

Risks and limits

Analysts cited by Al Jazeera warn that a free-standing three-way meeting could treat allies as secondary and trade their interests without consulting them. Others say the leaders’ interests diverge too sharply, on Ukraine, Taiwan and technology, for a formal bloc to emerge. A Russian analyst said that if nothing is produced by Christmas, it will be just a photo opportunity.

The practical test is modest. Look for a statement on Ukraine at all, any change in Russia’s insistence on Donbas, and whether Europe is brought into the process. Putin has ruled out meeting Zelensky until a final deal is ready, so a breakthrough in Shenzhen would still leave the hardest decisions to Kyiv.