Photo: Murray Close/Lionsgate

With Sunrise on the Reaping, the Hunger Games Movies Try for a Vibe Shift

by · VULTURE

The best thing that can be said about The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping — and it’s not a small thing — is that this one has some good old-fashioned Hunger Gaming in it. It’s been more than a decade since the original dystopian young-adult movie series starring Jennifer Lawrence concluded its run. Since then, author Suzanne Collins has published two prequels, the first of which, The Ballad of Songbirds & Snakes, was adapted for the screen in 2023. That last film, charting the origin story of the series’ chief villain, President Coriolanus Snow, did feature an early version of the Hunger Games, the grisly annual competition in which select young people from the dystopia of Panem are pitted against each other in a TV-ready survival battle to the death — but that primitive iteration was confined to a dingy, small arena. And 2015’s Mockingjay — Part 2 had a brief, symbolic competition at the end, but really, it’s been a while since we’ve gotten a proper Hunger Games, the kind with a vast, high-tech woodland terrain populated by creatively lethal dangers. That was part of the original conceit of this saga, and it made for some cruelly rousing drama. By that metric alone, Sunrise on the Reaping delivers. And some of the perils we get this time around include electrified butterflies, man-eating squirrels, toxic pollen, and a rather conveniently placed volcano.

ad-position slots="mobile_article_body"

The new story picks things up four decades after Songbirds & Snakes and a quarter-century before the original Hunger Games. Our hero is 16-year-old Haymitch Abernathy (Joseph Zada), who in the earlier films was played by Woody Harrelson as the embittered, alcoholic, kindhearted mentor to Lawrence’s Katniss Everdeen. Now we get to see Haymitch as a golden-locked young man (this series sure does love its blond boys) who winds up getting chosen for the 50th annual Hunger Games after he intervenes to protect his girlfriend, Lenore Dove (Whitney Peak), from Panem’s ruthless storm troopers. Resolutely opposed to the Hunger Games and determined to keep his fellow competitors safe, Haymitch is enlisted by a group secretly working to undermine the Games. He is also singled out by the all-seeing President Snow (once played with fanged glee by the late Donald Sutherland, now played with catatonic sobriety by Ralph Fiennes), who, as always, seems to be one step ahead of his adversaries. Other characters from the earlier films also return as their younger selves. Kelvin Harrison Jr. shows up as tech wiz and resistance bomb-maker Beetee, once played by Jeffrey Wright; Elle Fanning takes on the role of the garish fashionista stylist Effie Trinket, once so memorably portrayed by Elizabeth Banks; and Jesse Plemons is Plutarch Heavensbee, the master media manipulator, future game-maker, and rebel leader previously played by the Philip Seymour Hoffman.

ad-position slots="mobile_article_body_med_rec_dynamic desktop_article_body mobile_leaderboard"

With so many returning characters whose eventual fates are already well established, Sunrise on the Reaping often feels like a foregone conclusion. We’re not exactly sitting around wondering if Haymitch will survive the Games. Of course he will — he has to become Woody Harrelson. Whether handsome Aussie Zada will survive the unfortunate drawl he sporadically attempts is another matter entirely; I don’t remember Harrelson being this incoherent. For sure, it can be distracting trying to catch glimpses in these new performances of the characters’ future selves. Maybe that’s why the one who comes off best is Kieran Culkin as the flamboyantly weird master of ceremonies Caesar Flickerman, once played by Stanley Tucci. Culkin is himself such an odd, unpredictable presence that it feels like he’s already been doing Caesar for years.

ad-position slots="desktop_article_body mobile_leaderboard"

The original Hunger Games films played out against a compellingly gray land, blasted out and broken, reflecting the agony of the characters. But the postapocalyptic fervor of the 2000s has abated a little, and these last two Hunger Games entries have tried to expand the gritty sensibility of the earlier pictures; Songbirds & Snakes was practically a musical, and Sunrise on the Reaping feels like an unapologetic melodrama. The new film is certainly more colorful and lyrical than previous iterations, and maybe even filled with a delusional kind of hope. Haymitch’s idyllic sojourns with his love, Lenore (yes, that is an Edgar Allan Poe reference), who communes with nature and speaks of eternal life, become memories he returns to during his darker moments. The romanticism doesn’t always work — Lenore isn’t fleshed out enough for Haymitch’s love to truly make an impact — but there’s still something charming about it.

ad-position slots="desktop_article_body desktop_article_body_1 mobile_leaderboard"

Maybe the film’s foiled attempts to find color, faith, and love have another purpose. Francis Lawrence, who has directed these movies ever since the second entry, Catching Fire, has a gift for depicting the nasty moral compromises required of young people trying to survive a totalitarian hellscape. Last year, he even took a break from the Hunger Games franchise to direct a long-awaited adaptation of Stephen King’s novella The Long Walk (which my colleague Alison Willmore described as “dude Hunger Games”). That picture’s dystopian competition simply involved an extended march to the death, but Lawrence knew which buttons to push to evoke just the right amount of solidarity, character engagement, and hope amid such overwhelming bleakness. We became wrapped up in the young men’s dramas, even though we knew that the story wasn’t going to end well for any of them. To put it more simply: Francis Lawrence is really good at making movies about kids dying. And in Sunrise on the Reaping, despite the pastoral settings and vivid color palette, he never lets the spiritual gloom dissipate. The disconnect feels intentional.

ad-position slots="mobile_article_body_med_rec_dynamic desktop_article_body desktop_article_body_1 mobile_leaderboard"

It might also be a nod to the stories’ changing idea of resistance. The YA craze of the past quarter-century or so has given us lots of tales about successful rebels, of heroes who bravely stood up to unjust worlds and managed to change them. Sunrise on the Reaping, by its very nature, can’t quite do that. It’s no spoiler to say that this is largely a story of failure. But it’s also one of persistence, of taking the hits and suffering and slowly persevering in the vague hope that things might improve someday. Maybe that’s an acknowledgment of a readership (and a viewership) that’s grown older and discovered that change doesn’t always come immediately — a maturing vision for a maturing audience. Maybe it’s just reality creeping in. Or maybe they just need to keep making more Hunger Games movies.

ad-position slots="desktop_article_body desktop_article_body_1 mobile_leaderboard"

Sign up for The Critics

A weekly dispatch on the cultural discourse, for subscribers only.

Become a Subscriber

Already a subscriber? Sign in

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
Vox Media, LLC Terms and Privacy Notice

By submitting your email, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Notice and to receive email correspondence from us.