Sinners Review: I Don't Know If I Love It More As A Crime Movie Or A Horror Movie. That's Awesome

Ryan Coogler's Sinners is a jaw-dropper.

There is nothing inherently wrong with a filmmaker taking on franchise titles, but it has been over a decade since movie-goers have seen an original feature from writer/director Ryan Coogler. He made his breathtaking debut in 2013 with the powerful Fruitvale Station, but since then has dedicated his focus to existing intellectual properties – first with Creed and then with the two Black Panther blockbusters. Each of those titles came with certain strings attached, but Coogler nevertheless showcased himself as an extraordinary talent. And now that he’s back to making pure originals, he has successfully crafted his best movie yet in Sinners.

Sinners

Release Date: April 18, 2025
Directed By: Ryan Coogler
Written By: Ryan Coogler
Starring: Michael B. Jordan, Miles Caton, Hailee Steinfeld, Jack O'Connell, Wunmi Mosaku, Jayme Lawson, Omar Benson Miller, Delroy Lindo, and Li Jun Li
Rating: R for strong bloody violence, sexual content and language
Runtime: 137 minutes

The film is a multi-faceted period epic that is so good in so many ways that it’s actually a challenge to identify its singular best quality – which I suppose makes its greatest aspect the ability to confidently juggle so much so well. I love it as a Prohibition era gangster story, with its colorful-but-shady fraternal protagonists building the business of their dreams in their home town. I love it as a fierce and dark vampire film that sets up a horrific siege with a freaky collection of sinister bloodsuckers. I love it as a celebration of Black music, both for its incredible musical sequences and comment on its power in the culture. And I love everything that ties all those branches and more together.

In a dual performance, Michael B. Jordan stars as twins Smoke and Stack, who return to their hometown in Mississippi after spending years away building reputations and lives for themselves in Chicago. Upon their return, it’s their ambition to use a great deal of cash at their disposal to purchase a mill and transform it into a juke joint to serve the Black community in the segregated South. They have whiskey and beer supplies to really get the party started, and their ace in the hole is their cousin Sammie "Preacher Boy" Moore (Miles Caton), who has turned himself to a tremendously talented guitar player and blues singer.

Their personal connections in the area allow them to find local help for the endeavor: Smoke’s estranged wife Annie (Wunmi Mosaku) does the cooking; Delta Slim (Delroy Lindo) and Pearline (Jayme Lawson) agree to perform; business owners Grace Chow (Li Jun Li) and her husband Bo (Yao) provides supplies and signage; and Cornbread (Omar Benson Miller) gets hired to watch the door. Amid this recruiting, however, conflict begins to brew – and not just because Stack’s former flame Mary (Hailee Steinfeld) discovers he is back in town. A vampire named Remmick (Jack O’Connell) arrives on the scene, and after doing a bit of recruiting of his own (Lola Kirke and Peter Dreimanis), he sets his sights on the opening night of Club Juke.

Ryan Coogler's Sinners introduces a rich world full of complex and wonderful characters.

It is long before vampires crash the party that Sinners successfully dazzles, as it doesn’t take bloodsucking monsters to invest the audience in the fates of the characters; the charisma and ambition they express takes care of that, as personality and spirit make you want them to succeed. There are shady actions behind the protagonist’s ability to purchase the mill and provide booze in light of the notorious laws of the era banning the production and consumption of alcohol (which itself adds to the stakes), but the non-capitalist goal of the juke joint is creating a safe space full of music and joy for a community in need of one, and it’s built on fantastic character dynamics in the Mississippi Delta.

Just when I thought I was getting a little fatigued of dual performances in 2025 (Sinners follows Osgood Perkins’ The Monkey, Bong Joon Ho’s Mickey 17, and Barry Levinson’s Alto Knights employing this cinematic trick), in comes Michael B. Jordan to deliver the best of them all. The sharp costume design by the great Ruth E. Carter provides an assist to the audience in coloring the characters – Smoke accented with blue, Stack accented with red – but those contrasting shades highlight their respective ice and fire personalities that set them apart from each other beyond sartorial choices. Working from Coogler’s dynamite script, Jordan, one of the best actors of his generation, provides both roles with complexity that reflects individual lives while also maintaining the loving connection of twins who have spent their whole existences together.

Jordan’s work is supported by an outstanding ensemble of personalities, and there is an openness and comfort in all of them that make the world feel perfectly lived-in (it helps that there aren’t exposition potholes that feel like the characters are explaining themselves to the audience instead of speaking to one another). From the phenomenal musical talent of Miles Caton’s Sammie Moore, to the humorous drunken no-bullshit attitude of Delroy Lindo’s Delta Slim to the trauma and spiritualism of Wunmi Mosaku’s Annie, Sinners provides a look into a collection of rich lives – and when it becomes a real threat, you really don’t want to see any of them getting their throats ripped out by creatures of the night.

Sinners is a stunning work of art that you shouldn't deprive your eyeballs of.

Ryan Coogler reunited with Black Panther: Wakanda Forever cinematographer Autumn Durald Arkapaw shooting Sinners entirely in IMAX, and the collaboration and expansive format yields breathtaking images long before the main action kicks off. But when that time does come, it hits a new level and becomes heart-stopping wonder. A truly great on-screen party makes you want to jump out of your seat and join the revelry, and Coogler’s work understands that… but it becomes so much more. When we look back on the decade that we are presently half-way though, I can say with complete confidence that we will look back on Sammie’s performance at Club Juke being regarded as one of the most incredible cinematic achievements of the era – the camera gliding through the space in a oner and examining every era of Black music, from the past to the present to the future. I’ve never seen anything like it, and it demands to be seen on the grandest screen available. (And a special hat tip must be proffered to composer Ludwig Göransson, whose work on the music instantly convinced me to purchase both the soundtrack and score).

The fact that all of this magnificence unfurls before the vampires truly enter the plot is stunning – and there most certainly isn’t any kind of quality dip as the film makes its From Dusk Till Dawn-esque switch-up in genre. Horror is a new flavor for Ryan Coogler, but so were boxing movies and Marvel blockbusters prior to his last three features, and he proves equally adept at bearing fangs and letting the blood flow. Sinners abides by traditions, like nightwalkers requiring invitation and weapons like stakes and holy water, but Coogler also has his own vicious ideas that he employs as he crafts his own metaphor with monsters. It’s a tremendous and fascinating nightmare.

There are only a few filmmakers left in Hollywood with the proper clout to execute singular, original visions with substantial budgets, and I’m beyond hopeful that Sinners will be viewed as Ryan Coogler’s ticket into the echelon that includes Quentin Tarantino, Jordan Peele, and Christopher Nolan. It’s a remarkable achievement from every angle, and a blissful cinematic experience.