Emergency exit 'always locked', bartender claims amid Swiss fire probe

A criminal investigation was launched yesterday into the French owners of the Swiss ski bar engulfed by a deadly inferno on New Year's Eve, amid claims that an emergency exit at the venue was 'always locked'.

Police announced that Jacques Moretti, 49, and his wife Jessica, 40, were being investigated on suspicion of manslaughter by negligence, bodily harm and arson after a horrific blaze killed 40 and injured 119.

The inferno at Le Constellation in the Alpine resort of Crans–Montana erupted in the venue's basement bar when sparklers in champagne bottles set a ceiling covered in insulation foam alight.

Harrowing video footage showed revellers, many of whom were teenagers, continuing to party as the flames spread across the ceiling, losing crucial seconds during which they could have fled.

The venue was branded a 'deathtrap' after it emerged that partygoers squeezed up a narrow staircase to escape the flames and toxic smoke in the basement.

But in a major development, it was yesterday claimed there was another potential escape route via an emergency exit within the basement – but that it was allegedly always locked.

Andrea, 31, a bartender who works elsewhere in the resort but was a regular at Le Constellation, told German newspaper Bild: 'There was an entrance that also served as an exit. And there was an emergency exit. But whenever I was there, it was always locked.

'Everyone in town knew things were bound to go wrong eventually.

'The emergency exit was in a separate smoking room. Hardly anyone used it; most went up to the conservatory. The smoking room was used as a kind of storage room. There was a sofa inside in front of the door, and carelessly discarded objects lay outside.'

Another witness, Grigori, who was on his way to the bar when the fire erupted, and whose friend is among the missing, said: 'There's another exit, but I think they were locking it because some people were escaping without paying.'

Read More

Pictured: How Swiss bar owners renovated club themselves - as they say they are 'very unwell'

The Mail on Sunday has also identified a third exit on the ground floor of the bar, which led into a covered shopping area that includes a ski rental shop. 

Anyone using that exit would then, however, have to go through another glass door to escape on to the street. It is unclear whether either of those doors were open or locked when the fire started at 1.30am.

The revelations came as a 16–year–old girl from Milan, Italy, was the second person to be named as a victim. Chiara Costanzo's father, Andrea, told an Italian newspaper he felt a 'great emptiness' after receiving a call 'that should never come to a father'.

'Until the very end we hoped that Chiara was among the injured admitted to the hospital but not yet identified,' he said. 'Then, without warning, the world collapses. You're never ready. You can't be.

'It's unnatural for a father to lose a daughter. I wish she wasn't 'just' a name on a list of victims. Because she was never a number. She was a beloved daughter.'

Italian national Emanuele Galeppini, 17 and a golf prodigy, was the first victim to be reported dead, with the news confirmed by the Italian Golf Federation on Friday.

Police yesterday said eight Swiss victims had been identified and their bodies released to their families. They are four women and four men, including two 16–year–olds. 

Dozens of families, however, continue to face an agonising wait as experts attempt to identify the remaining 30 victims and five of the most seriously injured.

'It's a wait that destroys people's stability,' said Elvira Venturella, an Italian psychologist working with the families. Those missing include French–born Charlotte Niddam, 15, who attended Immanuel College, a private Jewish school in Hertfordshire, and the Jewish Free School in North London.

Read More

Firefighters who braved Swiss ski resort inferno honour victims they couldn't save

One of her friends, Summer Chesler, yesterday posted a video montage showing the pair dancing together with the caption: 'I miss my best friend.'

Another friend, Sophie, shared a separate TikTok video with a caption that read: 'My heart has broken. Please come home Charlotte, we are all waiting for you.'

Sixteen–year–old Arthur Brodard is also among the missing. His mother Laetitia, from Lausanne, Switzerland, said: 'There are five unidentified people in hospital [but] the authorities refuse to tell us where they are, in which country, in which canton. Anger is starting to rise. There are more than 30 parents looking for our children.'

Stephane Ganzer, state councillor in charge of the Department of Security, said the identification of victims was 'a top priority', acknowledging the 'unbearable wait' endured by families.

Mr Moretti yesterday appeared for the first time since the tragedy, near a restaurant he owns in the nearby village of Lens. He refused to answer questions from the MoS.

Meanwhile, last night's episode of ITV's The Masked Singer scrapped a performance of the song Disco Inferno, which featured dancers in fire suits, 'owing to potential insensitivities'.