(From left) Russian President Vladimir Putin, Chinese President Xi Jinping and US President Donald Trump arriving for a trilateral meeting at Kylin Villa on the sidelines of the APEC Summit in Shenzhen, China, on Nov 19.
PHOTO: AFP

Trump’s camaraderie with Xi and Putin draws pushback at home

· The Straits Times
  • Trump’s warm meetings with Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin in China drew criticism at home, as the optics suggested US weakness and gave Beijing a stronger global role.
  • The trip produced few concrete results. Trump avoided hard pressure on China over advanced AI chips and on Russia over Ukraine, despite ongoing war and security concerns.
  • White House aides called the trip a success, but critics said it ignored voter worries about costs, cyber risks and inflation, and may have only short-lived gains.

WASHINGTON – On his two-day trip to China this week, US President Donald Trump glad-handed and exchanged hugs with Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin in an effort to flex his power after his Republican Party suffered a midterm election blowout at home.

The imagery and symbolism of the meeting with the Russian and Chinese leaders often had the opposite effect.

He offered plaudits and praise instead of pressuring them on matters of disagreement. His warm exchanges with the US’ foremost geopolitical rivals belied the outsize tensions between them and further undercut Trump’s standing with American allies and national-security hawks.

The iconic photo of the three-way summit, with Xi at the centre and Trump and Putin at his sides, visually delivered Beijing a status it has long sought: a dominant seat at the table presiding over the world’s great powers. 

“The summit showcased the three leaders doing the most to destroy American power,” said Kori Schake, a former Bush administration official now at the American Enterprise Institute.

“An electorally weakened US President, stripped of both the allies and ideas that make America internationally dominant, allowed Russia to escape isolation and pretend to be a great power while China presided with no mention of its economic subterfuge of US tech firms.”

Trump’s encounter with Putin on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) leaders’ meeting intensified his quixotic effort to end Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine, yet it also kneecapped international attempts to isolate the Russian leader, whose armed forces continue to attack Ukrainian cities and civilian targets. 

On China, Trump passed up an opportunity to confront Xi over alleged efforts to gain access to advanced American artificial intelligence chips, amplified by the Nvidia scandal, even as some of his own advisers have warned that US export restrictions are too lax.

Trump has long pursued a different foreign policy from that of his predecessors, one guided by direct diplomacy with American adversaries and scepticism of traditional alliances. Yet after more than half a decade in the White House, his critics say the strategy has borne little fruit. 

As he flew back to Washington, Trump posted on social media that the trip was “great and highly consequential” and said he would hold a White House news conference on Nov 20 to talk about its achievements, including trade frameworks struck with Thailand and the Philippines.

Trump said he spoke about the conflicts in Iran and Ukraine with his counterparts, as well as AI. But concerns about China’s efforts to obtain sensitive US technology and the need to pressure Russia to scale back its attacks on Ukrainian targets did not appear to be top of mind for Trump when speaking about his interactions.

Instead, he spent the final day of the trip highlighting his friendship with Putin and his “outstanding” bond with Xi, including in trilateral talks at a lush villa outside the Chinese technology hub of Shenzhen.

“It’s an honour to be here with you, Vladimir. It’s an honour to be with you, Mr President,” Trump said, referring to Xi. He called each man a “friend”.

The bonhomie on display in Shenzhen also risked striking a discordant note with Americans at home, who in recent days had experienced a series of anxiety-inducing disruptions to air travel, telecommunications and banking. 

An ocean away from those domestic crises, Trump merely downplayed them, creating a split-screen effect as technology outages dominated news coverage.

“Tell them to relax. Everything’s good,” he said in a Fox News interview from China on Nov 19. 

That messaging threatens to amplify criticisms that Trump has lost touch with voters on issues ranging from the high cost of living and inflation to the risks posed by AI and cyberattacks.

Isaac Stone Fish, founder of Strategy Risks, a business intelligence firm focusing on China, said that while Trump made the right decision to go ahead with the trip, its priorities seemed far removed from the issues the American public was focused on.

“I don’t know of any domestic constituency that was clamouring for Trump to meet with Xi and Putin,” he said.

Anna Kelly, a White House spokeswoman, said Trump “effectively restored American strength – and his events in Asia showcased the great respect and deference that world leaders bestow upon our country under this President’s bold leadership. President Trump will meet with anyone in order to advance our country’s interests”. 

In his opening remarks at the APEC summit, Trump said US inflation had been tamed, comparing other countries’ fights with high prices unfavourably with Washington’s work on the issue.

That position does not square with the feelings of many in the American electorate, who voted Republicans out of their majorities in Congress largely because of anger over the high cost of petrol and goods, fuelled by Trump’s tariffs and the conflict with Iran.

Trump touted the trilateral meeting with Putin and Xi for weeks, expressing lofty ambitions such as the unlikely prospect of convincing Beijing to rein in its nuclear weapons stockpiles. At the same time, he dismissed more immediate concerns, saying, for example, that he did not need their help to resolve the war in Iran. 

In the end, the much-anticipated meeting, which had allies and other nations fearing that they would be cut out of major geopolitical decisions, offered few – if any – concrete outcomes, beyond talk of reforming the UN, curbing the International Criminal Court, continuing discussions on nuclear weapons and uncertain pledges to boost supplies of petroleum products.  

“There was very little of substance, but there was a lot of, I think, bad optics for the Western democracies,” said Mary Lovely, a senior fellow at the Peterson Institute for International Economics, citing Putin’s criticisms of Western governments and international organisations. 

“It looks like three very powerful men who seem to be criticising the current global governance architecture and replacing it with basically nothing,” she added. 

Trump said the reception he received was a win for the nation itself. When asked by Fox News how Americans would view the trip as a success, the US leader said he had “already gotten that headline, because the relationship that I have with China is a great one”.

“The fanfare, the beauty, the pageantry, the thousands of people, the young children, the soldiers, the whole thing,” he recalled of his arrival in Shenzhen. “It was a great respect, and I appreciate that. That’s a big win for us. It’s a big win for China too.”

Upon his return to Washington, Trump may also find that the good feelings from the summit are short-lived.

On Air Force One, as he departed China, Trump called into a meeting of Ukrainian allies to tell them that a separate face-to-face meeting with Putin had gone well and would advance efforts towards a ceasefire. 

Putin, though, has already promised to step up attacks on Ukraine, saying earlier on Nov 19 that he would respond to an attack that damaged a key bridge between Russia and occupied Crimea. 

China this week also warned the US over restrictions on its access to cutting-edge AI chips and servers.

Trump, for his part, seemed eager to avoid any chance of offending his hosts, dismissing the espionage concerns by saying that both sides spy on each other and that he did not think there was a national security risk from the Nvidia revelations. BLOOMBERG