Joey Chestnut Returns to Nathan’s Hot Dog Eating Contest

Mr. Chestnut, who was barred last year over an endorsement deal with a vegan-meat company, and Miki Sudo easily won their respective contests but did not break records.

Joey Chestnut, the perennial champion of the Nathan’s Famous Hot Dog Eating Contest, made headlines last year when a falling-out with the event’s organizers led to his being barred from competing, shocking fans nationwide.

But on this sweltering Fourth of July, outside the Nathan’s flagship restaurant at the corner of Surf and Stillwell Avenues in Coney Island, Mr. Chestnut, 41, returned to the men’s division of the competition with a vengeance, and spectators were riveted as he devoured 70.5 hot dogs and buns in 10 minutes.

Though he didn’t beat his personal best of 76, Mr. Chestnut easily outmatched last year’s champion, Patrick Bertoletti, 40, who consumed only 46.5 hot dogs.

Mr. Chestnut pumped his fist in the air in triumph. When asked how he felt about returning to the throne he had held for 16 years, Mr. Chestnut said, “I love being here.” He assured the crowd, “I’ll be back next year.”

Temperatures reached the high 80s as the sun beat down on the midday competition, making conditions less than ideal for record-breaking. It was also a rough day for Miki Sudo, the reigning champion of the women’s division, who has 11 victories under her belt. She won handily with 33 hot dogs but fell short of her record of 51, which she set last year.

Ms. Sudo, 39, conceded that she had not been feeling her best and attributed her performance to the buns’ being “more doughy than usual.”

“It’s OK,” she said. “A win is a win.”

Mr. Chestnut was barred from last year’s competition after he entered an endorsement deal with a Nathan’s rival, Impossible Foods, which makes vegan hot dogs.

George Shea, the contest’s boisterous M.C., told The New York Times that year that Major League Eating, the self-proclaimed “governing body of all stomach-centric sports” that oversees the event, had no choice but to part ways with Mr. Chestnut.

But Mr. Shea said that the organizers had “never stopped talking” with Mr. Chestnut, and the dispute was resolved in time for this year’s contest. A spokesman for Major League Eating said the organization was “really excited to have him back,” calling his return “a great success.”

Mr. Shea said he was ecstatic that Mr. Chestnut had returned to the competition, calling him “shy of a god, perhaps, but more than a man.”

Some of Mr. Chestnut’s fans had traveled across the country to witness his comeback. Sean Neal, 31, said he had flown from Dallas to Philadelphia and then taken a train to New York for the contest.

“There was a lot of excitement to hear they squashed the beef,” he said. “They got to bring him back.”

Others were attending the contest for the first time, including Charlie Burge and his wife, Jeanine, of East Hampton, N.Y. Mr. Burge held a sign that proclaimed, “Joey Chestnut, I want to have your baby!”

“I wanted the sign to be an attention-getter,” he said.

Mr. Burge, 58, said Mr. Chestnut had passed by him on the way to the contest but had not spotted the sign. But he didn’t take offense.

“He’s got a lot on his mind,” he said, adding that he hoped there would be another chance to intercept the champion, maybe after his win.

There were plenty of other signs to encourage Mr. Chestnut. “Guzzle the glizzys,” said one. “Chestnut for President,” said another. One woman in the crowd, presumably a Taylor Swift fan, held a sign that read, “This is my Eras tour.”

As it became apparent on Friday that Mr. Bertoletti — who ate 58 hot dogs last year — would not catch up to Mr. Chestnut, Mr. Shea declared, “Joey Chestnut is here to make a statement.”

When Mr. Chestnut began to slow down his bites, Mr. Shea goaded him for not being able to meet his previous record.

“An incredible performance, but he doesn’t have the time,” Mr. Shea said when there were still four minutes left in the contest. “No human can do it.”

The contest has been held by Nathan’s since the early 1970s — contrary to urban legend and P.R. narrative, which claims it started in 1916 when Nathan Handwerker, the company’s founder, opened a stand at the corner of Stillwell and Surf.

Though Mr. Bertoletti and other competitors showed up on Friday intent on surpassing their rival, all eyes seemed to be on Mr. Chestnut. But one Brooklyn resident, Paul Calienes, was not especially impressed by his return.

“I’ve been here way longer than Joey,” said Mr. Calienes, 58, standing near the bus that had driven the contestants to the contest, wearing a star-spangled outfit. He has attended the contest since 1996, he said.

He added that it was “messed up” that Mr. Chestnut could not participate last year.

“Joey Chestnut is going to get his title back,” Mr. Calienes said. “Unless Bertoletti gets his stomach pumped, or something.”

Around the New York Region

A look at life, culture, politics and more in New York, New Jersey and Connecticut.

• At 91, His Latest Big Case: Judge Frederic Block will oversee the prosecution of a Mexican drug lord, which could end in a death penalty. He also does stand-up comedy.
•  Graduation in the Time of ICE:: A Bronx high school dedicated to recently arrived immigrants paid tribute to a Venezuelan student who was sitting in a migrant detention center.
• A Routine for an ‘Italian Fairy’ : Simona Rodano barely has time to strap on her sparkly wings before she dashes around the city, teaching children how to sing in Italian, French and Spanish.
• Metropolitan Diary:  Read about a flash of lime green in Park Slope, a museum beckons and more reader tales of New York City..