Let Siraj, Jadeja fail on their own: Ashwin slams India's 1st Test selection calls
R Ashwin slammed India's decision to drop Mohammed Siraj and Ravindra Jadeja for the Wellington Test, calling the selection call "absolutely crazy". He believes both players deserved the chance to fail on their own terms.
by India Today Sports Desk · India TodayIn Short
- Ashwin called India's decision to drop Siraj and Jadeja absolutely crazy
- He said both players deserved a chance to fail on their own terms
- Ashwin feels India missed Siraj's skills once the ball got old in Wellington
R Ashwin had spoken about the calls to drop Ravindra Jadeja and Mohammed Siraj from the playing XI for the Wellington Test on X. He called it a harsh call but said it was the new normal within the Indian team.
IND vs NZ 1st Test, Day 1: HIGHLIGHTS | SCORECARD
He then answered a fan and said it was a sarcastic remark by him and he wasn't a fan of the call. Speaking on his YouTube channel, Ashwin expressed his anger with the call made by the team management for the Wellington Test.
Siraj and Jadeja had been heroes for India in their last overseas tour in England. Siraj picked up 23 wickets and bowled the most overs for India as he often stepped up in the absence of Jasprit Bumrah. Jadeja, on the other hand, was prolific with the bat, scoring 516 runs.
Yet, both men failed to get a spot for the match in Wellington and Ashwin found it to be absolutely crazy. The former spinner said he saw this trend during the ODI series and was actually thinking Siraj was being preserved for the Tests.
"This is a trend. When these things happen, we have to speak up. It is not about who is playing, when he is playing or where he comes from. But what happened today is something that will keep happening. And this is absolutely crazy!"
"What is going on? Ravindra Jadeja scored 500 runs in the previous away series. He is now sitting out. Mohammed Siraj, in the absence of Jasprit Bumrah, helped India draw the England series. What does that tell you?"
"We had seen this trend during the ODI series as well. Siraj was not being picked. I thought perhaps they were keeping him fresh for the Test series. Prasidh Krishna is returning from injury. Anshul Kamboj has played only his second or third Test after featuring in England, and now he is playing again."
"Perhaps Siraj's pace has dropped. You can have an opinion on Ravindra Jadeja, but both these players have contributed so much to Indian cricket that they deserve a chance to fail on their own terms," said Ashwin.
India batting coach Sitanshu Kotak said that the selection of Washington Sundar over Jadeja was due to the presence of too many left-handers in the New Zealand lineup.
But Ashwin pointed out the flow in the argument. He felt that with all four pacers on both sides being right-handers, the rough would have been created outside the off-stump for left-handers, helping Jadeja in the process.
"Look at the number of right-arm seamers in this match. There are eight of them: Anshul Kamboj, Akash Deep, Prasidh Krishna, Jasprit Bumrah, Nathan Smith, Kyle Jamieson, Matt Henry and Jacob Duffy. Most of their overs will be from one end. That means a patch will develop on one side, and it could become rough for the left-handers as well when the second innings comes around."
"In overseas Test matches, spinners often play a wicket-taking role in the fourth innings, on the fourth or fifth day. By then, rough patches and potholes will have developed," said Ashwin.
'INDIA NEEDED SIRAJ IN WELLINGTON'
India started Day 1 on the front foot, but their advantage vanished the moment Henry Nicholls and Glenn Phillips started to get into a rhythm and the ball started to get old.
After Bumrah's spell, the rest of the bowlers failed to chip in and allowed New Zealand to get away. This is where Ashwin feels that a free-spirited cricket like Siraj was important for India.
"When nothing was happening with the old ball, India needed a bowler with the kind of attitude Mohammed Siraj brings. I am not saying that if Mohammed Siraj had played this game, he would have taken five wickets."
"But you need someone in your attack who is free-spirited, who runs in and bowls every time. Yes, Siraj also leaks runs, but he manages to do something or the other. He has been doing that for so many years and has shown it," said Ashwin.
Ashwin also criticised India captain Shubman Gill, saying that he needs to start taking decisions of his own when it comes to team selection.
"I think the captain also needs to own some of these decisions. Ultimately, the captain takes the team he wants onto the field."
"I feel there needs to be a little more balance in decision-making. I understand that there is a transition and that new players need to come into the team. I accept all of that."
"But at least in this format, experience has to count for something. It has to count for something that a player has been there and done it," said Ashwin.
Siraj's exclusion from the team came as a shock to many apart from Ashwin as Sunil Gavaskar and Ravi Shastri tore into the decision to bench him.
It remains to be seen if this decision will come to hurt India by the time the Wellington Test comes to an end.
- Ends