Why Aaron Boone stuck with lefty hitters in ugly Game 2 loss

What is the point of having a six-man bench full of right-handed hitters if you are only going to use one across three innings against a lefty reliever with your season fading away?

That was the scenario the Yankees faced Monday night in Game 2 of the ALDS against the Rays, trailing 5-1 in the sixth inning when Ian Seymour entered the game.

Access the Yankees beat like never before

Join Post Sports+ for exciting subscriber-only features, including real-time texting with Greg Joyce about the inside buzz on the Yankees.

Try it free

Aaron Boone had left-handed hitters Luis García Jr. and Spencer Jones hit for themselves in the sixth inning, then stuck with three more lefties in the seventh (Jazz Chisholm Jr., Trent Grisham and Austin Wells), with Seymour retiring all of them.

Finally in the eighth, Boone pinch hit Paul Goldschmidt for Ryan McMahon, though the veteran righty bat hit a harmless pop-up on the way to another meager offensive performance outside of Ben Rice’s two solo homers.

“Seymour I view as very neutral,” Boone said Tuesday. “So there would’ve been a right-hander I would have used at some point had we gotten runners on base, but by the time he was in the game it was 5-1. So I was playing more of a get on base, see if we could create traffic and then possibly shoot [Giancarlo Stanton] or Goldie or [Heliot] Ramos in a spot there.”

This year, lefties hit .244 with a .789 OPS against Seymour while righties hit .217 with a .683 OPS.

During a regular season in which the Yankees leaned on him heavily, using him in 81 of their 161 games, Brent Headrick mostly delivered, including allowing only 14.8 percent of inherited runners to score — which ranked sixth among qualified relievers.

But after he looked to be running out of gas down the stretch, the left-hander’s dip in velocity has carried over into the playoffs.

His fastball averaged 93.2 mph (down from his season average of 94.1) in Monday’s Game 2, which included giving up a two-run single to Richie Palacios in the fifth inning after a George Lombard Jr. error extended the inning.

“I think we’ve seen velocity from anywhere from 91 to 94 in the last couple outings, so if we can keep him in the 94 range, there’s definitely plenty of effectiveness there,” pitching coach Matt Blake said Tuesday.

“Striking the slider has — obviously — has become a priority, using the offspeed effectively, which he’s done in the second half of the year. Using the splitter a little bit more to the righties, leaning into the slider to both lefties and righties and then he’s got to be effective with his command of the fastball, and ultimately that’s where we’re at this time of year. He’s been used a lot and he’s doing his best to stay fresh down the stretch, but ultimately we got to keep making pitches when it’s important at this time of year.”

After arriving back in New York early Tuesday morning, the Yankees had an optional workout at Yankee Stadium, though Boone had said Monday he hoped most of his players would “stay away” to get some rest.

Shop Yankees Merch

New Era 2026 Postseason 59Fifty Fitted Hat

Celebrate the Yankees’ playoff run with the official New Era 2026 Postseason fitted hat. Features a classic navy design and side patch.

$52.99
Fanatics
Buy Now

Nike Aaron Judge Alternate Limited Jersey

Rep Aaron Judge in this premium Nike jersey. Breathable mesh and Dri-Fit technology keep you cool while cheering on the Yankees.

$174.99
Fanatics
Buy Now

’47 Brand Branson Adjustable Cap

Show your Yankees pride every day with this classic ’47 Brand Branson adjustable cap. Available in multiple colors for a comfortable, custom fit.

$34.00
Amazon
Buy Now

New York Yankees 2026 MLB Postseason Hoodie

Gear up for October baseball with this midweight Yankees Postseason hoodie. The perfect layer for staying warm during every nail-biting inning.

$85.00
Fanatics
Buy Now

Nike Aaron Judge Nike Graphic T-Shirt

Back the captain in comfort with this standard-fit Nike Aaron Judge tee. Features a high-density name and number design on the back.

$67.39
Amazon
Buy Now
New York Post may be compensated and/or receive an affiliate commission if you buy something through our links.

“Whatever guys feel like they need to do today … hopefully guys were able to sleep at least a little bit and kind of recover today,” Boone said. “And I’m sure there will be some guys in, at least moving around and doing some things behind the scenes to be ready to go [Wednesday].”