Smartphone AI, like Siri and Gemini, has a credibility crisis – a true agentic interface is the logical next step
It's worse than you think, and also inevitable
· TechRadarOpinion By Philip Berne published 30 December 2025
(Image credit: Getty Images/Alexsl) Share Share by:
Share this article 0 Join the conversation Follow us Add us as a preferred source on Google
I despise smartphone AI. It is arguably the most regressive development in consumer electronics, a spectacular misstep for mobile technology. The deeper I dive into so-called mobile AI, the more I’m left slack-jawed, wondering how features so fundamentally flawed could ever hit the shelf.
While AI’s potential is undeniable, today’s obsession with this shiny bauble is eroding the reputation of the world’s most formidable technology companies like Apple, Lenovo and Google, and there seems to be no alternative course.
Is the situation truly dire? It is worse than that. Imagine a Casio TI-84 calculator occasionally delivering an incorrect sum. Imagine a version of Microsoft Word that introduces, rather than corrects, misspellings. Imagine a national newspaper fabricating a front-page story. Today’s smartphone AI is a failure that surpasses these hypotheticals.
The reality is more insidious. What if that Casio calculator offered undeserved praise for your algebra mistakes? Imagine Microsoft Word not as a copy editor, but a plagiarist ghostwriter that steals the best prose. Think of a newspaper that uses doctored images to personally accuse you, the reader, of armed robbery, complete with fabricated stills of you removing a ski mask and counting illicit cash.
This is a more accurate depiction of the crisis of consumer AI. It is not merely wrong. It is not simply prone to error. It is actively harmful. The generative AI features in particular – image generators, text synthesizers, summary tools – are worse than incorrect. They are vectors for harm.
Tech companies will tolerate anything on the way to true AI
I’ve seen smartphone AI tools report baseless falsehoods, deploy harmful racial or misogynistic stereotypes, and facilitate fraud and deception. The consumer benefit of AI today is non-existent. AI has not made today's phones superior to yesterdays'. Nobody purchases a device because its AI suite is a marvel of utility.
No one shops for the best AI phone.
Get daily insight, inspiration and deals in your inbox
Sign up for breaking news, reviews, opinion, top tech deals, and more.
Contact me with news and offers from other Future brandsReceive email from us on behalf of our trusted partners or sponsors